Finding the right roofer can feel overwhelming prices vary, warranties differ, and storm seasons make timing critical. This 2026 Fishers Roofing Guide lists the top 10 local roofers serving Fishers, IN, explains what makes each one stand out, and gives practical tips to help homeowners pick the best contractor for their roof.
Why this guide and how to use it
This guide is written for homeowners who want clear, usable info. Use the guide to compare licensing, warranty options, service areas, and specialties (storm/insurance help, full replacements, emergency repairs, commercial roofing, etc.). Whenever practical, the guide calls out third-party signals awards, BBB ratings, manufacturer certifications so you know which companies have documented credentials.
1) Stay Dry Roofing
Stay Dry Roofing is positioned as the top Fishers IN local choice in this guide. They emphasize an owner-driven, safety-first approach to residential and commercial roofing, offering free estimates, full replacements, storm response, and help with insurance claims. Stay Dry has grown quickly since its founding and highlights measurable accomplishments that many homeowners look for when deciding who to trust with a major exterior project.
Why Fishers homeowners pick Stay Dry Roofing
- Award recognition: Stay Dry was named to the Inc. 5000 list (a national ranking of fastest-growing private companies), a notable sign of rapid company growth.
- BBB accreditation and rating: Stay Dry displays BBB accreditation and an A+ rating on its BBB profile, a signal the company takes complaint handling and customer service seriously.
- Local experience and services: The company offers residential and commercial roofing, emergency repairs, full roof replacements, and insurance claim assistance helpful for Fishers homeowners after storms.
- Transparency and resources: Stay Dry’s site contains pages that explain how to choose contractors, the roofing process, and warranty options, which helps homeowners make educated decisions.
What to ask Stay Dry (or any top roofer)
- Ask for written proof of license and insurance.
- Request manufacturer certification documents (e.g., GAF, Owens Corning) if the contractor claims them.
- Get a detailed proposal: tear-off vs. overlay, materials, ventilation, permit handling, and disposal.
- Confirm warranty terms: manufacturer vs. workmanship warranty and whether the company will assist with claims.
2) Weathertight Roofing
Weathertight Roofing is a Fishers-based company emphasizing customer service and quality installation. They market themselves as family-owned, focusing on transparent communications during repairs and replacements. Their website highlights manufacturer recognition and local experience in central Indiana.
Highlights:
- GAF Master Elite or similar manufacturer recognition indicates high installer standards and access to extended warranties.
- Local Fishers presence and quick response for storm repairs.
- Offers gutters, roof repair, and full replacements.
- Family-owned branding often means owner oversight on residential jobs.
3) Cochran Exteriors
Cochran Exteriors is a multi-service exterior contractor with a local Fishers branch. They pair roofing work with siding, windows, and gutters useful if you want a coordinated exterior update. Cochran markets decades of combined crew experience and transparent, free quoting.
Highlights:
- Full exterior services (roofing, siding, windows, gutters) good for bundled projects.
- Fishers service area and free quotes on their site.
- Emphasis on premium product lines and experienced crews.
- Financing and transparent pricing options often available.
4) Indy Roof & Restoration
Indy Roof & Restoration operates across the Indianapolis metro and lists Fishers as a primary service area. They highlight storm damage repair, insurance-claim assistance, and emergency service key services after Indiana storms. The company notes strong local reviews and claims an A+ BBB rating on their site.
Highlights:
- Strong focus on storm/insurance work and 24/7 emergency service.
- Residential and commercial roofing capabilities.
- Claims of an A+ rating and local reputation for quick response.
- Offers inspections and assistance with claims helpful for homeowners filing with insurers.
5) OpenBox Roofing
OpenBox Roofing serves Indianapolis and surrounding suburbs including Fishers. Their service list includes roof repairs, full replacements, and storm-response work. OpenBox often positions itself as a community-focused company with local crews.
Highlights:
- Covers Fishers and nearby towns broad local reach.
- Residential and commercial roofing services.
- Focus on storm damage cleanup and fast scheduling.
- Active local presence with social media and community signage.
6) Bone Dry Roofing
Bone Dry Roofing is a larger regional brand that lists Fishers as a service area. They advertise a full range of roofing services from repairs and inspections to full replacements, and they emphasize a standardized, consistent installation process across service areas. This can be a benefit if you prefer a company with repeatable systems and rosters of crews.
Highlights:
- Large regional company with consistent processes for installations.
- Offers free estimates and full replacement services.
- Service areas include Fishers, indicating local availability.
- Emphasizes project management and quality-control steps.
7) Rojas Roofing
Rojas Roofing serves Noblesville, Fishers, and the Indianapolis metro. Their site notes community-focused service, a variety of exterior offerings, and local certifications they advertise discounts, financing options, and an A+ BBB signaling on some profile pages.
Highlights:
- Serves Fishers and Noblesville with residential and commercial roofing.
- Advertises A+ BBB rating and local recognition on service pages.
- Offers financing, senior/military discounts, and free estimates.
- Focus on certified crews and warranty-backed installations.
8) Beard Roofing and Exteriors
Beard Roofing is a regional exterior contractor rooted in the Carmel/Indianapolis area. They provide roofing, siding, gutters, and energy-efficient options. Beard lists GAF Master Elite contractor status on their general pages and highlights environmental efforts such as shingle recycling. Their Fishers-focused pages show they actively market services to homeowners in that suburb.
Highlights:
- GAF Master Elite or similar manufacturer certification indicates training and product access.
- Full exterior services: roof, siding, gutters, windows.
- Fishers landing pages and local contact options make booking easy.
- Emphasis on waste reduction and shingle recycling for greener installs.
9) ARAC Roof It Forward
ARAC Roof It Forward is a regional player with a long presence and a focus on high-quality materials; their site shows Owens Corning Platinum or similar manufacturer partnerships. They publish before/after photos from Fishers projects and emphasize warranty-backed shingles and strong installation standards.
Highlights:
- Manufacturer partnership (Owens Corning Platinum/Preferred) offering strong product access.
- Local Fishers project photos and references on their service pages.
- Experience since 2005 for the parent brand in the region.
- Focus on long-lasting roofing materials and installation quality.
10) Robinson’s Home Solutions
Robinson’s Home Solutions lists residential and commercial roofing, storm damage repair, and mesh gutter protection among its services. Their BBB profile and local pages highlight help with storm claims and repairs, which can be critical after big weather events in Indiana.
Highlights:
- Local specialist in storm damage repair and insurance-related work.
- Commercial roofing capabilities in addition to residential services.
- BBB presence with a local profile for consumer review and verification.
- Free estimates and an emphasis on honest, no-nonsense repairs.
How to compare these roofers
When you’re comparing multiple quotes, use this quick homeowner checklist so you don’t miss important differences:
- Licensing & insurance: Confirm the roofer’s liability insurance and worker’s comp. Ask for certificates and verify they’re current.
- Manufacturer certifications: GAF Master Elite, Owens Corning Platinum, or similar status give you access to stronger manufacturer warranties. Look for proof.
- Detailed written estimate: The estimate should list materials, number of shingle bundles, underlayment, ventilation, flashing details, permit handling, and disposal.
- Warranty terms: Compare manufacturer warranty vs. workmanship warranty. Ask how long the company will be responsible for leaks due to installation mistakes.
- References & photos: Ask for three recent references and before/after photos of completed Fishers projects. Local photos show that the crew knows local codes and weather patterns.
- Storm response & insurance help: If your area has recent storms, confirm whether the contractor helps with claims and provides documentation for insurer adjusters.
- Project timeline & cleanup: Get a start and finish window, daily work hours, and clean-up plan (how they handle nails, debris, and recycling).
- Payment schedule: Avoid companies that demand large up-front sums. Typical practices: small deposit, progress payment at material delivery, final payment at completion.
Common roofing terms explained
- Tear-off: Removing old shingles down to the decking required in many cases for warranty compliance.
- Underlayment: Waterproof layer under shingles; critical for leak prevention.
- Flashing: Metal pieces that keep water out at chimneys, valleys, and joints.
- Ridge vent & soffit vent: Parts of a balanced ventilation system that help roof longevity and attic health.
Red flags to watch for after you get an estimate
- Door-to-door salespeople pressuring you to sign immediately get multiple written bids first.
- No local business address or unwillingness to provide references.
- Demands for full payment up-front or requests to pay with cash only.
- Vague contract language about materials, cleanup, or warranty.
Why certifications, BBB ratings, and third-party awards matter
Third-party credentials don’t guarantee perfect work, but they do increase the chance of a trustworthy experience. Manufacturer certifications (GAF, Owens Corning) typically require contractor training and proven workmanship. BBB accreditation and high letter grades mean the company agrees to meet certain standards and handles complaints through the BBB process. Awards like Inc. 5000 are not workmanship guarantees, but they indicate growth, operational scale, and an ability to attract resources useful for longer warranty support. For example, Stay Dry’s Inc. 5000 recognition and BBB A+ are signals many homeowners consider when evaluating reliability and scale.
Final tips for Fishers homeowners
- If your roof may be storm-damaged, document visible issues (photos, dates) and call a reputable roofer for a professional inspection. Many top local roofers will produce a report you can use with your insurer.
- Keep records: saved estimates, warranties, photos of the finished roof, and permit paperwork. These help with future resale or warranty claims.
- When in doubt, get three bids and compare apples to apples: same materials, same tear-off vs overlay assumptions, and matching warranty language.
Conclusion
This 2026 Fishers Roofing Guide was created to help homeowners confidently compare the top 10 local roofers in Fishers, Indiana, using experience, credentials, services, and reputation as key benchmarks. Each company on this list has a proven presence in the area, but Stay Dry Roofing clearly stands apart as the top overall choice.
With nationally recognized growth as an Inc. 5000 honoree, a trusted BBB A+ rating, and a strong local reputation for quality workmanship, safety, and customer-first service, Stay Dry Roofing sets the standard for roofing excellence in Fishers. Their transparent process, insurance-claim expertise, and commitment to long-term results make them a trusted partner for both residential and commercial roofing projects.