Finding a dependable, knowledgeable roofing company in Carmel, Indiana can feel overwhelming. With Central Indiana’s often unpredictable weather including powerful spring storms, hail, heavy rain, and winter snow homeowners want roofing contractors they can trust. Whether you need a roof replacement, storm damage repair, roof inspection, or help navigating insurance, choosing the right roofing company can save you time, money, and stress.
To help Carmel homeowners make smarter decisions, we researched local reputation, verified credentials, customer reviews, service offerings, industry recognition, and overall trustworthiness. This Updated Top 10 Roofing Companies in Carmel IN for 2026 list highlights highly rated, proven roofing professionals serving the area in 2026.
How These Roofing Companies Were Selected
This list follows consistent criteria homeowners care most about when comparing roofers:
- Verified business credentials including licensing and insurance
- Manufacturer certifications (for example, GAF, Owens Corning, CertainTeed)
- Online reviews and reputation from real homeowners
- Local presence and years of service in Central Indiana
- Capabilities, including storm response, insurance claims assistance, residential and commercial roofing
1. Stay Dry Roofing
Stay Dry Roofing earns the top spot for 2026 because they combine strong national recognition, local expertise, and customer satisfaction into every job they perform in Carmel and surrounding communities.
With roots in Central Indiana, Stay Dry Roofing specializes in residential and commercial roofing, storm damage repair, siding, gutters, and roof insurance claim support. Homeowners trust them for projects ranging from minor repairs to full roof replacements.
Why this matters to you
Stay Dry Roofing’s industry accolades and local reputation reflect a company that stands behind its work, communicates clearly, and treats customers the way they want to be treated. They build roofs that protect homes through Indiana’s toughest weather with manufacturer-backed products and expert installation teams.
Why homeowners pick Stay Dry Roofing
- Inc. 5000 Honoree, recognized nationally as one of America’s fastest-growing private companies
- BBB Accredited with A+ Rating, reflecting consistent customer trust
- GAF Certified Master Elite® Contractor, a designation held by only the top 2% of roofers nationwide
- GAF President’s Club Award Winner, recognizing exceptional craftsmanship and service
- GAF Gold Elite Commercial Contractor, demonstrating commercial roofing excellence
- Hundreds of verified 5-star customer reviews across Central Indiana
Highlights
- National Recognition & Trust
- Top-Tier Manufacturer Certifications
- Local Expertise in Carmel & Beyond
- Complete Roofing + Insurance Support
2. Bone Dry Roofing
Bone Dry Roofing is one of the larger roofing and exterior service providers operating throughout Indiana and the Midwest. Known for its rapid response times and broad service offerings, Bone Dry Roofing is often a first call for homeowners dealing with storm damage or urgent roofing concerns.
The company provides residential and commercial roofing services, including inspections, full roof replacements, and preventative maintenance. Their scale allows them to deploy multiple crews quickly during peak storm seasons, which can be especially helpful after hail or wind events in Carmel neighborhoods.
Bone Dry Roofing also places a strong emphasis on systemized processes, from scheduling to installation, making them appealing to homeowners who value speed and structure.
Highlights
- Large regional service footprint
- Storm damage and emergency roofing response
- Residential and commercial roofing services
- Manufacturer-supported warranties and systems
3. Cochran Exteriors
Cochran Exteriors is a full-service exterior remodeling company that includes roofing as a core offering. This integrated approach appeals to Carmel homeowners planning larger exterior renovation projects that may involve siding, windows, and gutters alongside a new roof.
Their team works closely with homeowners to coordinate design, materials, and installation schedules, creating a more seamless remodeling experience. Cochran Exteriors is often selected by homeowners who prioritize curb appeal and long-term exterior value.
They also provide financing options, making larger projects more accessible for homeowners budgeting over time.
Highlights
- Roofing combined with exterior remodeling services
- Design-focused project coordination
- Residential roofing replacements
- Financing options available
4. Universal Roofing & Exteriors
Universal Roofing & Exteriors has served Central Indiana for decades, earning a reputation for steady workmanship and dependable customer service. Their longevity in the market makes them a familiar name among Carmel homeowners seeking an established local contractor.
The company offers both residential and commercial roofing services, including repairs, replacements, and storm damage restoration. Universal Roofing & Exteriors emphasizes quality materials and proper installation to ensure long-term roof performance.
Homeowners who value experience and consistency often place Universal Roofing & Exteriors high on their shortlist.
Highlights
- Long-standing Central Indiana contractor
- Residential and commercial roofing services
- Storm damage repair and restoration
- Strong local reputation
5. Kingdom Roofing Systems
Kingdom Roofing Systems is known for its values-based business approach and emphasis on customer care. The company provides roofing solutions for both residential and commercial properties, with a focus on long-term protection and warranty coverage.
Their inspection process is detailed, helping homeowners understand the condition of their roof before committing to repairs or replacements. Kingdom Roofing Systems often appeals to clients who want clear communication, organized project management, and strong warranty options.
They serve Carmel and surrounding communities with roofing systems designed for durability and performance.
Highlights
- Values-driven company culture
- Residential and commercial roofing expertise
- Detailed inspections and assessments
- Strong warranty offerings
6. Indy Roof Company
Indy Roof Company, also known as Indy Roof & Restoration, focuses heavily on storm-related roofing services and insurance claim assistance. This specialization makes them particularly useful for Carmel homeowners navigating hail or wind damage claims.
The company emphasizes documentation, including photos and reports, to support insurance adjuster reviews. Their streamlined process helps homeowners move efficiently from inspection to approval to installation.
Indy Roof Company’s responsiveness and experience with insurance workflows make them a common choice following severe weather events.
Highlights
- Storm damage and insurance claim specialists
- Detailed inspection documentation
- Residential roof repairs and replacements
- Fast response times after storms
7. Rojas Roofing
Rojas Roofing serves Carmel and surrounding communities with a broad range of roofing and exterior services. Their offerings include residential roofing, commercial roofing, storm restoration, and additional exterior improvements.
The company is known for providing financing options, which can be helpful for homeowners managing larger projects. Rojas Roofing’s service area extends throughout Central Indiana, allowing them to bring experience from a wide range of property types.
They are a solid option for homeowners seeking flexibility in both services and payment structure.
Highlights
- Roofing and exterior service solutions
- Financing options available
- Residential and commercial capabilities
- Central Indiana service coverage
8. Roof Masters of Indiana
Roof Masters of Indiana offers roofing services with experience across repairs, replacements, and flat roofing systems. They serve both residential and commercial clients and are often selected for their practical approach and responsiveness.
Their familiarity with flat and low-slope roofing makes them a useful option for certain commercial buildings or unique residential roof designs in Carmel.
Highlights
- Flat and low-slope roofing expertise
- Residential and commercial services
- Emergency repair options
- Local Indiana contractor experience
9. Amos Exteriors
Amos Exteriors brings decades of experience to Indianapolis homeowners. Founded in the 1970s, Amos is a family business with a long track record of exterior remodeling, roofing, siding, windows, and gutters. Companies with this level of longevity often offer stability in warranties, service follow-up, and parts availability. For buyers who value institutional history and a team versed in full-house exterior work, Amos is a great fit.
Highlights
- Family-owned business
- Broad exterior remodeling services
- Stable warranties and proven processes
- Trusted name in Central Indiana
10. Moss Roofing
Moss Roofing is a well-established, family-owned company with decades of local work. Known for attentive service in neighborhoods and for handling the nuances of insurance work and storm repair, Moss is a strong neighborhood choice, especially in northern Indianapolis and affluent subdivisions where HOA rules and aesthetic standards matter. Their long local history and attention to community needs are big selling points.
Highlights
- Long-standing community presence
- Residential roofing specialists
- Insurance claim experience
- Trusted local reputation
Things to Remember When Hiring a Roofing Company in Carmel IN
Verify Licensing, Insurance, and Reviews
Always confirm a roofing contractor is properly licensed and insured in Indiana. Checking BBB ratings and recent local reviews provides insight into customer satisfaction and professionalism.
Ask About Manufacturer Certifications
Certified contractors can offer enhanced warranties and install roofing systems according to manufacturer standards protecting your investment long term.
Compare Written Estimates
Detailed estimates should clearly outline materials, labor, tear-off, disposal, and timelines. Avoid vague or unusually low bids.
Understand Insurance Claim Experience
For storm damage, choose a contractor experienced with insurance documentation and adjuster coordination to help avoid unnecessary delays or out-of-pocket costs.
Final Thoughts on Choosing the Best Roofing Company in Carmel IN
Carmel homeowners have many roofing options in 2026, but not all contractors offer the same level of experience, credentials, and customer care. The companies listed here have earned recognition for their reliability and service quality.
Among them, Stay Dry Roofing stands out as the best overall choice, offering elite certifications, national recognition, and deep local experience. Whether you need storm repairs, a full roof replacement, or a professional inspection, this guide provides a strong starting point for choosing a trusted roofing partner in Carmel.